When do people cross that invisible indeterminable line that decides when can you forgive a person and when can you not?
Consider for example Ajmal Amar Kasab-he's obviously done something thats totally unforgivable and you'd be hard put to find even some people who would be willing to allow him to let him turn over a new leaf and start over. I'm definitely not one of them.
But what about other stuff like someone telling in on you, betraying you in business/relationship, backstabbing you, insulting you, treating you like filth?
Would you forgive them? What if they had done something totally unforgivable? For example consider how hard would it be for parents to forgive the rapist who destroyed their daughters life?
I totally empathize with the parents...its unforgivable...the worst thing anyone could ever do...I'm sure many people would say that such a guy deserves to rot in hell.
But regardless of how it may sound, there is still the other side to the coin that we have not yet seen. That we, blinded by righteousness choose to ignore because our mentality doesn't let us go in the minds of the accused.
I do not say that all cases are like that.
And that is the doubt in my mind-how do you decide who is unforgivable and who is worth giving a second chance?
Take the above example of the rapist. That guy might have been sexually abused himself(or even herself) when they were a kid. Yes, that happens!
Childhood sexual abuse is much more common than we people are aware of.
And hence, what if the rapist had himself been assaulted regularly, again and again when he was what, like 8 years old?
Imagine the traumatic effect such an event would have on his psyche.
His whole life he would fear any sort of intimacy, start at the slightest physical gesture!
Then teenage, adolescence, sexual maturity-would be tough to cope with.
If you come to know all these facts about the rapist-would you then be able to say concretely, without any doubt, that he deserves to "rot in hell"?
I feel, any parents who would be able to forgive such a person, are very very "developed souls".
Now, lets go even deeper into the situation of this rapist. What if you would have been his mother/father/brother?
Then?
What would you be going through if you came to know all this? Would you then feel that he deserves to "rot in hell"?
Begging for forgiveness would be more likely, I believe.
How easy would it be for the these parents to forgive the accused, and how tough for the "victim"'s parents to forgive?
Is forgiveness then a matter of the relationship you have with the so-called "accused"?
Who would the actual accused be, in this case? The rapist? Or the person(s) who assaulted him? Or Fate?
I'd suggest no one, no one, is accused.
We are all "bhogis"-we simply pay for our karma.
All that is, is karma.
It was the karma of the girl that led her to suffer such physical abuse, it was karma of the person who inflicted abuse on her that led him/her to be abused in childhood. It was karma of the parents of the girl, that their daughter had to suffer such.
Who is to blame, hence?
I believe, no one.
Never can you blame anyone that they did this this that that thing to you. Everything is our own responsibility. We have no right to point fingers at anyone else or blame them that "you did this to me" or "You are the reason I'm in this mess" or "how dare you say so and so to me".
I believe fundamentally, no one, once again -NO one, can hurt us. Everything that comes to us, happens to us, is what we had sometime in the past, sent out.
Where does the question of forgiveness arise then?
I'd also like to point out, before we think that should we forgive them or not-once, once we should really step into their shoes, or maybe their closed ones' shoes and really know how is it to be on the other side of the bars.
The guy who raped must be suffering in guilt unimaginable himself. This is undeniable-all those who do wrong, know somewhere in their conscious/subconscious that they did something they shouldn't have. They regret it. They suffer. Day after day. Year after year. They might not know the reason for their suffering consciously, but somewhere they are aware, that their karma is getting back at them. Their parents must be cursing their fate and themselves. But would they not want to help both the "victim" and the "accused"?
Think about it.